We chose to dine at Cafe Spaghetti knowing nothing about it, we were only staying in New York briefly and only ended up choosing Cafe Spaghetti after being denied reservations at several more prestigious restaurants. This being said, eating at this Cafe was one of the most rewarding and memorable experiences I had during our New York escapade. Passionate foodies like myself subconsciously attempt to mark restaurants down due to small, insignificant details like lavatory conditions and cleanliness; I think that it is safe to say that Cafe Spaghetti ticked every imaginable box. As soon as we arrived we were graciously welcomed by a beaming receptionist. We were smoothly shown to our designated table where we were seated and made comfortable. We then set our gazes on a mouthwatering menu which we soon found out was just as delightful as promised. In a matter of minutes, we were attended to by a kindly waitress. We elected to order two mouth-watering starters: Three fabulous fried rice balls which were crispy on the outside yet cloudy and comforting on the inside. We also ordered an appetizing plate of dainties that appealed to all tastes. From luxurious prosciutto to creamy burrata, these delicious starters set the scene for the dreamy main courses that were to come next... My main course, the Ragu alla bolognese was delivered swiftly and was, in my opinion, perfect. A divine blend of juicy but meaty bolognese spread evenly and thoroughly over high quality, Italian pasta. The other entrees ranged from a simple yet pampering pasta with butter, to a complex, flavorful, and succulent sausage Orecchiette. Everybody demolished their meals with vigor and gusto, however, some reserved room for a tiramisù which seemed to be one of the restaurant's signature dishes. A short but tantalizing wait yielded the most spectacular, the most striking tiramisù I had ever consumed. I don't like telling people what to eat in my reviews but this tiramisù is a must-get to anyone with a sweet tooth. A perfectly cooled, tented dining space filled with the sound of Italian music goes phenomenally well with the rich and comforting food of Cafe Spaghetti. All in all I would certainly come again and hope this review encourages other people to come to this amazing restaurant. Five stars!

Really enjoyed out last visit. We had the chicken milanese, which was huge, can definitely be shared amongst a couple of people. The crab penne pasta was really good, had some nice chunks of crab and the sauce was really tasty (a bit spicy which was awesome). The pasta with sausage and brocolli was also really good. Was very kid friendly. The back yard / patio seating was fully enclosed, so the atmosphere was pleasant with the air conditioning providing some relief from the summer heat.

We sat outside( private party inside) It's clean, well lit. We never felt abandoned. Our server was very attentive. Made some suggestions and was able to accommodate an Allium allergy We started our brunch with several appetizers. Rice balls, burrata cremosa, prosciutto, cherry tomatoes, grill ciabatta, all so flavorful, plentiful The romaine Caesar with fried egg , and the breakfast spaghetti ( a first for us and so delicious) was a huge hit. The portions were just right. A man would come by and ask how we were, if we needed anything. Now we see why this Cafe is so popular. The service and food is flawless!

Wow! Blown away. Every single thing we ordered was a straight HIT. We got: Caesar salad, caico e Pepe rice balls, chicken Milanese, crab rigatoni and tiramisu + spumoni ice cream. I didn't try the oricchette but my friend loved it. The service was fast and super accommodating. The general manager was a sweetheart and really felt at home. Ambiance was super cute and cozy but the outdoor patio is where we were sat- totally takes you out of NYC. I can't say enough good things about the restaurant. I'd come back in a heart beat and can easily say this is one of my top favorite restaurants that I've tried in BK. Next time I must try the fussili grosso! My favorites on the table were the rice balls, crab rigatoni and salad must orders!

Made a reservation for a weekday and had a great meal here! I tried: + Olive oil martini + Romaine Caesar + Short rib ravioli + Orechiette + Patrizia's eggplant parm + Cannoli + Tony's tiramisu There were a few lows (salad was merely fine; the eggplant parm was too salty) but mostly highs. I particularly loved the martini and tiramisu, and the pastas were really solid. Good service, too!

I ate until I couldn't eat anymore. And I don't regret it one bit. A first time, been forever on my bucket list, dinner at Cafe Spaghetti certainly met my expectations. At the recommendation of friends who have dined here many times, it was my turn to finally check them out. I'm glad I did in their company. Service was very attentive by the welcoming staff and the backyard/patio ambience was cute and quaint. Wasn't sure what to order as far as drinks were concerned. My go to Aperol Spritz wasn't an option since they didn't carry Aperol. I ordered the Spaghetti Spritz. Opinion? Didn't appeal to my tastebuds. It tasted odd and I wasn't sure which alcohol served as the main ingredient. Not only was it very bitter but I wasn't a fan of the olives included as garnish. We ordered a medley of appetizers for the table: *Arancini (no meat, delicious and recommend), *Ricotta Crostini (recommend)--creamy and sprinkled with Hazlenuts. *Brussel Sprouts (meat on the side)--pretty good but somewhat overcooked/mushy. *Caesar Salad--kind of bland and wouldn't order next time. *Spiedini--fried bread stuffed with cheese. I didn't try it. *Eggplant Parm--delicious and decadent but on the salty side. For main, I was undecided between the Spaghetti with Vongole versus the Rigatoni with Crab. At the server's recommendation, I opted for the Crab Rigatoni. Happy I did. The portion was adequate and the taste was sublime. Mini Rigatoni with Just the right amount of cream integrated with the deliciousness of the crabmeat. It also had a spicy kick due to the Jalapeño. I inhaled this dish accompanied by a glass of red wine which had smoky and spicy notes. For dessert, we shared the Spumoni which was satisfying. Perhaps not as authentic as others but quite good. Overall, my opinion of Cafe Spaghetti was favorable. I think some dishes shine while others are average. Still, my experience was satisfying and I'd definitely return and recommend. *Side note: David Harbour from Stranger Things was sitting at the table behind us. My friends pointed him out because i wouldnt have known.

Went here for the first time two nights ago. We came for a birthday dinner and were sat in the back. From the outside and intial steps inside this looks like a quaint italian restaurant, which is the exact vibe we were hoping for, but then as you are led to the back the space completely opens up and there is ample seating. The service was friendly and well-paced. We started off with the burrata, ricotta crostini, and baked clams. All were amazing however the burrata was nothing special, I would skip that if anything. The ricotta and calms were both amazing and so flavorful, wonderful way to start of the meal. For mains I got the rigatoni mezze (served with crab--pictured below), also tried the chicken Milanese, bolognese, and branzino. All were so so good but I did enjoy my pasta the most. It was spicy and creamy and perfectly Al dente. Everything was very good though. No complaints. Lastly, for dessert, we had the lemon sorbet, hazelnut gelato, and Nutella bombolonie. All were sooo good, but would recommend the sorbet as it was most refreshing and light after a big meal. Also for the birthday they brought out 2 sparkler candles and sang, made it all the more special. Would most definitely come here again!

Tried the Bolognese, Butternut Squash Pasta and Milanese at Cafe Spaghetti. The Butternut Squash Pasta stole the spotlight, but the others were good too. Service was good... nothing memorable which is a good thing. They really pack people into the space which actually gives a nice homey feel.

Came back here for a date this past weekend and was reminded again just how special this restaurant is. The garden is an absolute vibe. The combo of romantic ambiance, delicious food and superb service make Cafe Spaghetti the perfect spot to impress friends, dates and family alike. The prices are quite reasonable too, given all of the aforementioned attributes. Shout out to my older brother who initial put them on my radar. Now, I get the privilege of shoutout them out far and wide on Yelp. It's a solid 5/5 from me!